Be Anon
>Bedtime for all prisoners
>You're in Sleepy's cell
>He's asleep
>Obviously
>This is the moment you've been waiting for
>Climbing into bed his bed you slowly take off your pants, being careful not to move too much
>You gently grab his asscheeks and slowly move forward
>You have to stifle a moan of pleasure as you finally enter him
>"Mmm, just like that Anon."
>He's dreaming about you 
>How sweet
>...
>Minutes pass
>You're almost at your limit
>Finally, you cum inside him
>You hop off the bed, pull your pants up and head for the door
>"Anon..."
>Oh shit he's awake
>This isn't good
>You hear him walk towards you
>He hugs you around your waist, pressing his face against your back
>You feel his gigantic horsesecock in between your legs
>"Come back to bed Anon."
>Life couldn't get any better
>Without hesitation, Sleepy picks you up in a bridal carry and gently places you on his bed
"Sleepy, please be gentle, I've never been on the receiving end."
>He leans forward and places a gentle Kiss on your lips
>"I will, I promise."
>He undresses you, then himself, and throws both your jumpsuits on the floor
>You marvel at the thing that's about to be shoved in your ass
>Slowly, you open your legs to invite him in
>He rubs the tip against your opening, teasing you
>His cock is so big that he doesn't even have to bend you over
>Slowly, it enters you
>You wince at the pain as he tries to bury it a little deeper
>"Anon are you alright, do you want me to stop?" 
"No, please keep going."
>He slowly pushes it in deeper, every centimeter bringing a shock of pain
>He finally stops when he realises that he's as deep as he can go
>You both lay still for a second
>He looks at you
>You nod
>He slowly begins moving back and forth going a little bit faster with each thrust
>It's happening, it's finally happening!
>Not too long afterwards, you start bleeding
>Tears of joy and pain are streaming down your face
>You have to  cover your mouth with both hands to keep from crying out
>Sleepy notices this and moves your hands away from your mouth, deciding to silence you with his lips instead
>He then lifts you up so that you're both in a sitting position
>You hop up and down on his dick as he continues thrusting
>The pain is almost unbearable, but the fact that it's being caused by Sleepy's massive horsecock makes it all worth it
>"Anon, I need to ask you something."
"What is it Sleepy?"
>"I want to know why you came into my cell tonight."
>Both your movements begin to slow down a little
"What do you mean?"
>"When you came into my cell, did you just want to bone me while I was asleep?"
>You know the real reason that you came in here tonight
>No, you didn't just want to bone him while he was asleep
>You always wanted to tell him something
>But you were just too afraid
"Sleepy, you know exactly why I came in here today."
>His pace speeds up a little
>"No, I want to hear you say it."
"Sleepy please don't make me-"
>He lifts you up, and quickly thrusts into you once
>You have to stifle a gasp
"Sleepy, you know why-"
>He does it again, this time you let out a little yelp
>"Please Anon, say it."
>Why is this so difficult?
>Each night you came in here promising yourself that you'd tell him
>But you never had the courage to do it
>Tonight has to be different
"Sleepy, I..."
>He looks into your eyes expectantly
"I..."
>Come on, just spit it out!
"Sleepy, I love you! Ever since we first locked eyes in book club, ever since we spoke to each other in the mess hall, I knew you were the only stallion for me!"
>He smiles at you
>"I love you too Anon!"
>He pulls you into a deep kiss
>Your tongues dance around in each others mouths
>After a while you both break away for air
>"Anon, I'm about too..."
"Do it Sleepy, I want it all inside of me!"
>You wrap your arms and legs around each other and he lets it all out
>A mixture of blood and semen spills onto the bedsheets
>You both sit there, panting for a few seconds before finally laying down together 
"Goodnight sleepy."
>"Goodnight Anon."
>The next morning you and Sleepy wake up in each others arms, still naked
"Good morning Sleepy."
>Sleepy doesn't say anything
>He must still be tired
>But when isn't he?
>He just gives you a peck on the lips and gets out of bed
>You both pick up your jumpsuits from off the floor and get dressed
>In the hallway, you notice a few other ponies looking at the both of you, smiling and giving nods of approval
>You also hear the things that some of them are saying
>"Aww that's too bad, I wanted him all to myself."
>"I had no idea either of them swung that way."
>"Even I can't make my wife scream that loud."
>"I knew that they belonged together, I just knew it!"
>You must not have been very quiet last night
>You're kind of embarrassed actually
>"Ok, lets go Anon."
>Sleepy smacks your ass to get your attention and starts walking towards the mess hall 
>You follow your new coltfriend, happy to know that you're about to have your first meal as a couple